+ Part 3 Hagar Road

Shelter Island | New York

Where Beauty

Is Humble

View Photos Watch Film 360° VTour Open House

Penelope Moore

Presented At

$2,349,000

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Living

3,312

SQFT

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 1

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 2

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 3

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 4

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 5

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 6

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 7

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 8

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 9

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 10

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 11

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 12

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 13

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 14

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 15

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 16

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 17

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 18

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 19

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 20

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 21

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 22

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 23

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 24

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 25

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 26

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 27

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 28

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 29

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 30

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 31

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 32

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 33

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 34

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 35

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 36

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 37

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 38

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 39

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 40

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. - Photo 41

+ Part 3 Hagar Road

Shelter Island | New York

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States. , Shelter Island , New York

Residential in Shelter Island

Set on 1.06 acres with elevated sunrise vistas, this freshly renovated single-story cottage is fully turn-key. The entry foyer, featuring a powder room and separate laundry room, opens to a bright, vaulted main living space that seamlessly combines living and dining areas, featuring a wood-burning fireplace with raised hearth. Strategically placed windows, including a striking round accent window near the ceiling, perfectly frame captivating views of blue sky and water. Glass doors open to an expansive 1109sf water view deck spanning the center of the rear of the home. The well-appointed kitchen, complete with a breakfast island and service area, is designed for effortless entertaining. The northern wing offers two guest bedrooms with water views, and a spa-like shared bathroom featuring double sinks, a soaking tub, and a separate shower. The spacious primary en suite includes two walk-in closets and a luxurious bath with a steam shower, double sinks, and a private commode room. On the southern side, a library with custom built-ins and water views offers a quiet retreat, with adjacent attached two-car garage and a staircase to the lower level. The partially above-grade basement provides storage and easy outdoor access, along with a generator hook-up for added peace of mind. Down the hill lies a rare offering: half ownership of a serene waterfront peninsula, a natural buffer between the home and shoreline. Meandering footpaths wind through this private sanctuary, where long-legged wading birds, tree toads, crabs, and diamondback terrapins have been seen

a perfect setting for nature lovers and quiet reflection.

For boaters, the property is near open waters and a boatyard with recreational amenities. Taxes for Part 3 Hagar Rd: $674.05. Taxes for 5 Hagar Rd: $6623.25

Gallery

3D Street View Tour

Property Location

5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States., Shelter Island New York

Local Weather & Climate

Shelter Island, New York

Current Conditions Updated recently

37 °F

Broken clouds

Feels Like 32°F

Humidity 73%

Wind 5 mph

Visibility 6.2 mi

Sunrise 10:54 AM

Sunset 10:59 PM

5-Day Forecast

Thu 19 Mar

Clouds

High 38°

Low 37°

Fri 20 Mar

Clouds

High 44°

Low 35°

Sat 21 Mar

Clouds

High 47°

Low 41°

Sun 22 Mar

Clouds

High 46°

Low 39°

Mon 23 Mar

Clouds

High 54°

Low 43°

Data from OpenWeatherMap

Walkability & Transit Scores

How easy is it to get around Shelter Island?

Walkability and transit scores for this address come from the EPA National Walkability Index.

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly payments for this property

Home Price

Down Payment

$100,000

Interest Rate

Loan Term

Estimated Monthly Payment $3,160

Monthly Payment Breakdown

Principal & Interest $2,528

Loan Amount $400,000

Total Interest $337,621

Total Cost $737,621

Potential Tax Benefits (United States)

$0 Est. First Year Interest Deduction

$0 Est. Annual Tax Savings

*Based on post-2017 tax law. Actual deductions depend on filing status, itemization, and current tax laws.

Ready to explore financing?

Connect with trusted mortgage partners

Important Information

This calculator is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute a loan offer, pre-approval, or commitment to lend.
Monthly payment estimates do not include property taxes, homeowner's insurance, HOA fees, or other applicable costs which may significantly increase your actual payment.
Interest rates shown are for demonstration only. Actual rates depend on your credit score, down payment, loan type, property location, and current market conditions.
This tool provides estimates only. Consult with a licensed mortgage professional for accurate quotes and personalized advice.
Tax benefit calculations are simplified estimates based on general assumptions for United States. Actual deductions depend on your specific tax situation, filing status, and current tax laws.
Tax Year Information: Tax data shown is based on United States tax year 2025 (fiscal year: January-December), rules effective from 2018 through 2025. Tax laws change frequently and may have been amended since this data was compiled.

Tax Information Disclaimer

The tax benefit information displayed on this page is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. This information:

Does not constitute tax advice and should not be relied upon as such. Tax laws are complex and vary by jurisdiction, individual circumstances, and are subject to change without notice.
May not be current or accurate for your specific situation. Tax rules are updated frequently by governments, and the information shown may not reflect the most recent changes.
Uses simplified assumptions that may not apply to your circumstances, including filing status, total income, other deductions, alternative minimum tax considerations, and local tax variations.
Should not be used as the basis for any tax planning decisions or financial strategies without consulting a qualified tax professional licensed in your jurisdiction.

Before making any decisions based on potential tax benefits, you should consult with a qualified tax advisor, certified public accountant (CPA), or licensed tax professional who can evaluate your specific circumstances and provide advice tailored to your situation.

Limitation of Liability: By using this calculator, you acknowledge that all results are approximations and should not be relied upon for financial, legal, or tax decisions. openluxe, its affiliates, officers, directors, employees, and agents expressly disclaim all liability for any damages, losses, or consequences arising from the use of or reliance on this calculator or the information provided herein. openluxe is not a lender, financial advisor, or tax professional and does not provide mortgage loans, financial advice, or tax advice. Use of this calculator does not create any professional relationship.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this property

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States have?

This house at 5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States features 3 bedrooms with 3,312 square feet of living space.

What is the size of 5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States?

This property offers 3,312 square feet of living space.

What is the listing price for 5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States?

This property is listed at $234,900,000, which equals $70924 per square foot.

What type of property is 5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States?

This is a house located in Shelter Island, New York. The property is situated in an established neighborhood with convenient access to local amenities and services.